Pope Leo XIV, the newly elected successor to Pope Francis, recently reaffirmed the Catholic Church’s stance against the death penalty during an interview with EWTN News amid a controversy over honoring pro-choice Senator Dick Durbin for his immigration advocacy.
Responding to questions about the tension between abortion opposition and capital punishment support, the Pope stated, “Someone who says ‘I’m against abortion but says I am in favor of the death penalty’ is not really pro-life,” emphasizing the Church’s clear teaching on human dignity from conception to natural death. He explained this view by urging Catholics to examine ethical issues holistically, fostering respect and dialogue rather than selective adherence to doctrines, as the Church has evolved to deem the death penalty inadmissible in all cases since Pope Francis’s 2018 revision of the Catechism.
This position starkly contrasts with many self-identified pro-life advocates, particularly in the U.S., who prioritize abortion bans as the core of their movement while defending the death penalty for heinous crimes, creating a perceived hypocrisy that the Pope directly challenged. Leo XIV extended this critique to immigration, adding, “Someone who says that ‘I’m against abortion, but I’m in agreement with the inhuman treatment of immigrants in the United States,’ I don’t know if that’s pro-life,” linking all three issues—abortion, capital punishment, and illegal aliens—as inseparable from a consistent ethic of life.
Online reactions erupted swiftly on platforms like X, with progressive Catholics hailing the statement as a bold continuation of Francis’s legacy, praising its call for comprehensive mercy and justice beyond mere anti-abortion rhetoric. Supporters, including theologians and activists, argued that true pro-life commitment demands abolishing the death penalty and welcoming immigrants.
Conversely, conservative voices decried the remarks as a liberal overreach, insisting that supporting the death penalty aligns with traditional teachings from St. Thomas Aquinas and Scripture, and does not negate opposition to abortion since pro-life focuses on the innocent. Critics like radio host Dan Proft labeled it theologically disappointing, noting the Church’s historical acceptance of capital punishment in extreme cases and viewing immigration enforcement as distinct from inhumane treatment. Overall, the statement has reignited debates within Catholicism, forcing adherents to reconcile selective moral stances with the Pope’s vision of undivided human dignity.
We want to ask you, the reader: do you support the death penalty? Answer in our poll below and comment your thoughts on the pope’s comments.
If you cannot see the poll, click here.
